Influence of biochar particle size on biota responses

Abstract

Despite the increasing interest for biochar as a soil amendment, a knowledge gap remains on its impacts on non-target soil and aquatic species. We hypothesised that biochar particle size and application rate can play a role in the toxicity to biota. Pine woodchip biochar was incorporated in a clean soil at three particle size classes: small (<0.5 mm), medium (1-2 mm), and large (<4 mm), and at two concentrations: 1% and 6% w/w. A laboratory screening with earthworm Eisenia andrei avoidance behaviour bioassay was carried out to test the most adequate application rates, particle sizes and soil-biochar pre-incubation period. Thereafter, a 28-day greenhouse microcosm experiment was conducted as an ecologically more representative approach. Survival, vertical distribution and weight changes of E. andrei, and bait-lamina consumption were recorded. Soil leachates from the microcosms were collected to evaluate their impact on Daphnia magna immobilisation and Vibrio fischeri (Microtox®) bioluminescence. A feeding experiment with E. andrei was also performed to address earthworm weight changes and to conduct a screening of PAH-type metabolites in their tissue. The 6% <0.5 mm treatment pre-incubated for 96 h induced significant avoidance of the earthworms. Significantly lower bait-lamina consumption was observed in microcosms for the 6% <0.5 mm treatment. Moreover, particle size was a statistically significant factor regarding the loss of weight in the feeding experiment and higher concentration of naphthalene-type metabolites detected in E. andrei tissue, when exposed to <0.5 mm biochar particles. The leachates had no adverse effects on the aquatic species. The results suggest that particles <0.5 mm of pine woodchip biochar can pose sub-lethal effects on soil biota.